Multifamily · New York, NY

What owners are underwriting in New York, NY multifamily

Deals are being levered to 66% at close.

Drawn from 11 underwriting models 3E builds and maintains for 5 owners and operators buying multifamily in New York, NY.

Updated 2026-10-14

The assumption stack

Exit caps, hold periods, leverage and coverage do not appear in any sale-comparable database. They exist only inside the model a buyer built. These are the medians across 3E's client underwriting.

From 3E client underwriting models11 properties

Hold periodYears from acquisition to the modelled sale.

5.0 yrs

5.0y8.1y

middle 50% · 9 models

Loan-to-valueLoan amount as a share of purchase price at close.

66%

65%74%

middle 50% · 10 models

Interest rateThe rate carried in the model at close.

6.75%

6.50%7.00%

middle 50% · 11 models

Operating expense ratioTotal operating expenses as a share of effective gross income.

28%

26%51%

middle 50% · 8 models

Levered IRRThe levered internal rate of return the model projects over the hold.

18.3%

16.4%22.5%

middle 50% · 10 models

A 5-year hold is the convention here. 44% of the 9 models carrying a hold period use exactly that figure. Where a business plan genuinely needs longer, the underwriting is doing something the rest of the market is not — worth being deliberate about.

Pricing

Two independent reads: what 3E's clients are paying, and what the wider market has transacted at. Where they disagree, the gap is usually the story.

Priced into 3E client underwriting11 properties

Price per unitPurchase price divided by unit count.

$378,095/unit

$293,174$443,476

middle 50% · 11 models

Market sale comparables417 sales · 2023–2026

Going-in cap rateYear-one net operating income divided by purchase price.

5.7%

5.0%6.7%

middle 50% · 99 sales

Price per unitPurchase price divided by unit count.

$399,336/unit

$195,690$576,309

middle 50% · 394 sales

Price per square footPurchase price divided by net rentable area.

$387/SF

$204$608

middle 50% · 414 sales

Market context

Public reference data for the market, and the hazard profile of the properties 3E is actually underwriting in it.

Metro demographics

Population: 19,756,722
Population, 5-year change: −1.2%
Median household income: $97,334
Median gross rent: $1,780/mo
Renter-occupied share: 49%

US Census Bureau, 2019–2023 ACS 5-year. New York-Newark-Jersey City, NY-NJ (CBSA 35620).

Natural hazard

In a FEMA flood zone: 0%
Median national risk percentile: 33
Heat Wave risk, high or above: 45%
Winter Weather risk, high or above: 18%
Hail risk, high or above: 9%

Across the 11 properties in this cut that carry a FEMA profile. Flood zone = Special Flood Hazard Area (1% annual chance). Risk percentile from the FEMA National Risk Index.

Rate environment

10-year Treasury: 5.21%
5-year Treasury: 5.00%
SOFR, overnight: 3.89%

Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis (FRED), as of 2026-10-13. The backdrop the rates above were underwritten against.

Method

Where the underwriting figures come from

3E builds and maintains acquisition and asset-management models for owners and operators. The figures above are medians across those models — 11 distinct properties in this cut. They describe what buyers are assuming, not what any property is worth.

Market context

Demographics are US Census Bureau ACS 5-year estimates for the metropolitan statistical area; benchmark rates are published by the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis. The hazard profile is not a statistic about the metro — it is computed across the 3E-modelled properties in this cut, using FEMA flood maps and the National Risk Index, and so describes what buyers here are actually choosing to underwrite.

What the ranges mean

The large figure is the median. The two smaller figures are the 25th and 75th percentiles — the middle half of the sample — and the tick marks where the median falls between them. A median hard against one end indicates a skewed sample, which is worth knowing before leaning on the number.

Run this on your deal

Send one OM or T-12 and 3E will underwrite it properly — model, sensitivities, debt sizing and a risk score — benchmarked against the figures above and delivered in the portal within three business days. No charge, and no meeting needed.

Email ebergin@3emanagement.org